Modern GRUBing: Difference between revisions

mNo edit summary
mNo edit summary
Line 1: Line 1:
Rocky Linux 9 does not use the /etc/default/grub and /boot/grub2/grub.cfg Files any longer.  Instead the BLS (Boot Loader Specification) 'method' is used.  If one reads the documentation from RedHat, it seems like thing got really messy (and confusing).
Rocky Linux 9 does not use the /etc/default/grub and /boot/grub2/grub.cfg Files any longer.  Instead the BLS (Boot Loader Specification) 'method' is used.  If one reads the documentation from RedHat, it seems like thing got really messy (and confusing).


==== Quick D for Cloning, err, "Recreating" a drive from a BackUp (IE, the closest thing to Acronis that Linux seems to have) ====
* Create a duplicate or functionally similar Partition layout to the original
** CFDISK and "Logical Volume Commands"
** Use Blivet from a Rocky 8 Live Boot Device<br />
==== Rough D ====
* Start from a 'Clean Slate': <code>wipefs -a /dev/sdX</code> (make dang sure the proper 'sdX' is chosen!)
* Set the Partition Type (MBR or GPT): <code>cfdisk /dev/sdX</code>, (select DOS or GPT, save it (write) )
* Create Partitions: cfdisk
** https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Partition_type
** Linux EXT4: $83 (that's Commodore Speaky for 83h)
** Linux LVM (and LVM2): $8E
* LVM Stuff using Commands or BLIVET
** <code>pvcreate /dev/sdX</code>
** <code>vgcreate VG.NVMe.ROOT /dev/sdX</code>
*** <code>vgrename WhatEverOldName WhatEverNewName</code>
** <code>lvcreate -L 64G -n LV.ROOT VG.NVMe.ROOT</code>
* BLIVET


====BLS (Boot Loader Specification)====
====BLS (Boot Loader Specification)====
Line 9: Line 29:


Look in /boot/loader/entries and / or use GRUBBY
Look in /boot/loader/entries and / or use GRUBBY
...see below for key information on /etc/default/grub and BLS


====GRUB "Installation" for MBR / BIOS====
====GRUB "Installation" for MBR / BIOS====
Line 66: Line 88:
*On '''UEFI systems''', <code>grub2-install</code> registers <code>grubx64.efi</code> with the UEFI boot manager using <code>efibootmgr</code>.
*On '''UEFI systems''', <code>grub2-install</code> registers <code>grubx64.efi</code> with the UEFI boot manager using <code>efibootmgr</code>.


=== More from ChatGPT on "GRUBing" ===
= '''Comprehensive Guide to Installing GRUB on Rocky Linux (UEFI & BIOS)''' =
This guide covers:
* '''UEFI bootloader installation''' on a target drive.
* '''Legacy BIOS (MBR) bootloader installation'''.
* '''BLS (Boot Loader Specification) and its effect on <code>grub2-mkconfig</code>.'''
* '''GRUB Boot Stages Explanation (Stage 1, Stage 1.5, Stage 2).'''
* '''How to properly configure bootloader entries and verify installation.'''
----
== '''1. Understanding GRUB Boot Stages''' ==
{| class="wikitable"
!'''GRUB Stage'''
!'''Description'''
!'''Applies To'''
|-
|'''Stage 1'''
|'''MBR code''' (first 512 bytes of disk) loads Stage 1.5 or Stage 2.
|'''Legacy BIOS (MBR) Only'''
|-
|'''Stage 1.5'''
|Located in the first 30KB after MBR, it helps find <code>/boot/grub2</code>.
|'''Legacy BIOS (MBR) Only'''
|-
|'''Stage 2'''
|Loads the GRUB menu, kernel, and initrd.
|'''Both UEFI and BIOS'''
|-
|'''UEFI Firmware Boot'''
|Uses the '''EFI System Partition (ESP)''' instead of MBR. Loads <code>grubx64.efi</code>.
|'''UEFI Only'''
|}
----
== '''2. Installing GRUB for UEFI Booting''' ==
=== '''A. Identify the Target Drive''' ===
List available drives and partitions:
Look for the '''EFI System Partition (ESP)''', usually '''formatted as FAT32 (<code>vfat</code>)'''.
Example: If the target drive is <code>/dev/sdb</code>, and the EFI partition is <code>/dev/sdb1</code>, mount it:
=== '''B. Bind System Directories (for Chroot)''' ===
If configuring an external system:
=== '''C. Install Required UEFI GRUB Packages''' ===
=== '''D. Install GRUB to the Target Drive''' ===
* <code>--target=x86_64-efi</code> → Specifies '''UEFI mode'''.
* <code>--efi-directory=/boot/efi</code> → Ensures GRUB is installed in the EFI partition.
* <code>--bootloader-id=rocky</code> → Labels the boot entry as '''"Rocky"'''.
* <code>--recheck</code> → Forces a re-scan of the drive layout.
=== '''E. Generate the GRUB Configuration''' ===
⚠ '''However, Rocky Linux follows BLS, which makes this step less critical''' (explained in Section 4).
----
== '''3. Installing GRUB for Legacy BIOS (MBR Boot)''' ==
=== '''A. Mount the Target Drive's Root Partition''' ===
If the system has a separate <code>/boot</code> partition:
=== '''B. Chroot into the Target System''' ===
=== '''C. Install Required BIOS GRUB Packages''' ===
=== '''D. Install GRUB to the MBR of the Target Drive''' ===
* <code>--target=i386-pc</code> → '''Required for Legacy BIOS (MBR) booting'''.
* <code>/dev/sdb</code> → '''Must be the whole disk (not a partition like <code>/dev/sdb1</code>)'''.
* <code>--recheck</code> → Forces a disk layout rescan.
=== '''E. Generate the GRUB Configuration''' ===
⚠ '''But due to BLS, <code>grub.cfg</code> is no longer the main configuration source.'''
----
== '''4. Understanding BLS (Boot Loader Specification)''' ==
Rocky Linux follows '''BLS (Boot Loader Specification)''', meaning '''boot entries are controlled by systemd-boot entries, not <code>grub2-mkconfig</code>'''.
=== '''How to Manually Manage BLS Entries''' ===
# '''List Existing Boot Entries:'''
# '''Manually Create a BLS Entry:'''
# '''Example BLS Entry (<code>rocky.conf</code>)'''
# '''Enable BLS Support in GRUB (if needed)'''
=== '''Why BLS Makes <code>grub2-mkconfig</code> Less Relevant''' ===
* '''Traditional GRUB entries are no longer used''' in Rocky Linux.
* The '''bootloader reads BLS entries instead'''.
* '''<code>grub.cfg</code> is still used for bootloader settings''', but '''kernel entries are controlled by BLS'''.
----
== '''5. Verify Installation''' ==
=== '''Check EFI Boot Entries (For UEFI Only)''' ===
=== '''Check GRUB Installation''' ===
=== '''Check BLS Entries''' ===
=== '''Reboot and Test''' ===
----
== '''6. Summary''' ==
{| class="wikitable"
!'''Boot Mode'''
!'''Target Option for GRUB'''
!'''Install Command'''
!'''Config Location'''
|-
|'''UEFI'''
|<code>x86_64-efi</code>
|<code>grub2-install --target=x86_64-efi --efi-directory=/boot/efi --bootloader-id=rocky</code>
|<code>/boot/efi/EFI/rocky/grub.cfg</code>
|-
|'''BIOS (MBR)'''
|<code>i386-pc</code>
|<code>grub2-install --target=i386-pc /dev/sdb</code>
|<code>/boot/grub2/grub.cfg</code>
|-
|'''BLS (Rocky Linux Default)'''
|<code>systemd-boot controlled</code>
|<code>bootctl list</code>
|<code>/boot/loader/entries/</code>
|}
<br />
<br />
== '''1. The Presence (or Absence) of <code>/boot/grub2/grub.cfg</code>''' ==
* If '''<code>grub.cfg</code> exists''', GRUB will parse it.
* If '''<code>grub.cfg</code> does NOT exist''', GRUB will attempt to '''read the BLS entries directly''' instead.
This means:
✔ '''Deleting <code>grub.cfg</code> forces GRUB to rely entirely on BLS.'''
✔ '''Regenerating <code>grub.cfg</code> (<code>grub2-mkconfig</code>) puts GRUB back into a "hybrid mode" where it may still reference BLS but also maintain compatibility with legacy boot setups.'''
----
== '''2. GRUB’s Bootloader Installation (<code>grub2-install</code>)''' ==
The actual bootloader installed to the disk controls whether it defaults to '''BLS mode or <code>grub.cfg</code> mode'''.
When GRUB is installed with:
(''where <code>/dev/sdX</code> is your boot disk, like <code>/dev/sda</code> or <code>/dev/nvme0n1</code>''), it does the following:
* Sets up '''GRUB’s core image''' (<code>/boot/grub2/i386-pc/core.img</code> for BIOS systems or <code>/boot/efi/EFI/rocky/grubx64.efi</code> for UEFI systems).
* Embeds the logic for '''how GRUB will find and load boot entries'''.
* If BLS is active, it instructs GRUB to '''skip parsing <code>grub.cfg</code> and go directly to BLS entries'''.
This means: ✔ If GRUB was installed '''with BLS enabled''', even if <code>grub.cfg</code> exists, it may not be used.
✔ If GRUB was installed '''without BLS support''', it will fall back to <code>grub.cfg</code>.
----
== '''How to Explicitly Switch Between BLS and <code>grub.cfg</code>''' ==
=== '''To Force BLS Mode (and Ignore <code>grub.cfg</code> Completely)''' ===
# '''Ensure BLS entries exist''':  If this folder is empty, something is broken.
# '''Delete <code>grub.cfg</code>''' (this ensures GRUB won’t use it):
# '''Ensure GRUB is installed with BLS support''':  ''(For UEFI systems; adjust for BIOS if needed.)''
# '''Reboot''' and verify that <code>grub.cfg</code> is no longer in use.
----
=== '''To Force Legacy <code>grub.cfg</code> Mode (and Ignore BLS)''' ===
# '''Ensure <code>grub.cfg</code> is present''':
# '''Reinstall GRUB to disable BLS mode''':  ''(The <code>--no-bootloader-spec</code> flag explicitly prevents GRUB from using BLS.)''
# '''Reboot''' and verify that <code>grub.cfg</code> is being used.
----
=== '''Final Answer''' ===
✔ '''The real switch between BLS and <code>grub.cfg</code> is NOT in <code>/etc/default/grub</code>—it's controlled by how GRUB is installed and configured.'''
✔ '''Deleting <code>grub.cfg</code> forces BLS mode, provided GRUB was installed with BLS support.'''
✔ '''Reinstalling GRUB with <code>--no-bootloader-spec</code> forces it to use <code>grub.cfg</code> instead of BLS.'''
✔ '''To change modes, you must either delete <code>grub.cfg</code> (to force BLS) or reinstall GRUB (to force legacy mode).'''